News

Petition to stop water fluoridation

THE OTHER SIDE: Chyina Lee and Drew Finlay, with their fact sheet about hydrofluosilicic acid, one of three approved forms of water fluoridation, about which these Whitsunday residents have concerns.
THE OTHER SIDE: Chyina Lee and Drew Finlay, with their fact sheet about hydrofluosilicic acid, one of three approved forms of water fluoridation, about which these Whitsunday residents have concerns.

WHITSUNDAY residents Andrew Finlay and Chyina Lee have started a petition in an effort to stop fluoridation of the region's water supply.

Mr Finlay, who has been researching the controversial topic, both on the internet and through a documentary film called 'Firewater', says in his opinion fluoride and particularly the commonly used compound hyrofluosilicic acid, is a "poison".

"It's a highly corrosive, dangerous chemical in its concentrated form," he said.

Mr Finlay says according to his sources, hyrofluosilicic acid is a by-product of phosphate fertilizer, manufactured by a company in Geelong.

"If people found out it was coming from a fertilizer company, I think they would ask a lot more [questions]," he said.

While fluoride also occurs in natural and pharmaceutical grade forms, Mr Finlay says he wouldn't support its addition to the water supply in any form "because it's already in toothpaste and it's in our salt".

"There's already enough of it," he said.

However, the immediate past president of the Australian Dental Association (ADA) Queensland branch, Dr Andrew Wong, says there are three compounds that have been approved for water fluoridation use, these being hydrofluosilicic acid, sodium fluorosilicate and sodium fluoride.

"Each has its advantages and disadvantages in terms of transport and ease of use [but] most councils, to my understanding, use sodium fluorosilicate," he said.

Dr Wong says, regardless of which compound is used, they all dissolve in water 100 per cent and are all regularly tested for both accuracy of concentration and contamination. Furthermore, Dr Wong is quick to point out that fluoride compounds are heavily diluted, making them "perfectly safe".

"In Queensland, the level of fluoride they aim for is 0.9 of a per cent of fluoride per one million parts of water," he said.

"This has been shown to be a level that's extremely safe yet effective at reducing dental decay."

Meanwhile, Mr Finlay and Ms Lee maintain it is important for Whitsunday residents to be informed and say there is still time to stop fluoridation from going ahead.

"There is a way and that is to sign this petition," Mr Finlay said.

"500 signatures creates a people's mandate that the State Government must respond to with their reasons for whether they accept or reject the petition to stop fluoridation in the area."

The petition can be found at www.change.org/petitions/whitsunday-regional-council-stop-the-fluoridation-of-whitsunday-region-in-2013. More information is available on the Facebook page titled 'Whitsunday Takedown Fluoride WTF'. Mr Finlay plans to hold screenings of the film 'Firewater' in Proserpine, Airlie Beach and Bowen, once appropriate venues have been found.

The dentist's view

Arguments for water fluoridation, put forward by immediate past president of the Australian Dental Association (ADA) Queensland branch, Dr Andrew Wong.

Water fluoridation is safe: The overwhelming body of scientific evidence supports water fluoridation as a safe and effective means of reducing dental decay across all age groups. It is supported by the World Health Organisation, Centre for Disease Control, National Health and Medical Research Council of Australia, the Australian Medical Association and the Australian Dental Association.

Regarding the [hydrofluosilicic] acid and its production: Yes there is an industrial process to make the compound but that would be no different to making chlorine, which we also add to our water supply. In regards to its toxicity, yes, if you consumed the compound in its concentrated form I am sure it would not be good for you, in the same way [as] if you drank from a vat of concentrated chlorine.

Water fluoridation works: Communities with water fluoridation have been shown to have between a 20-40 per cent reduction in dental decay.

Water fluoridation is cost effective and saves the community money: While there are some initial costs (which the State Government should cover for councils), the ongoing cost to fluoridate is low compared to the cost of treating dental decay.


Join the Community.

Get your local news, your way.

Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

Girl in paradise video evokes Airlie pride

World traveller Nina Wilson, who grew up in the Whitsundays, has made a video showing off the region.

Video captures the beauty of the Whitsundays

Sporting clubs rally against domestic violence

Proserpine and Whitsunday Junior Rugby League Club president Kevin Young and under 16s team Joel Hoffman, Ben Young, Nick Dierna, Josh Colborne, Aden Spence, Oakley Ngakura, Jack Durnsford, Jake Harrison and counsellor Jan Waetford (back), with Jack Handley, Mitch Cann, Ben Cornish, Malachai Lane and Brad Barbeler (front). Photo Lucy Smith / Daily Mercury

Rugby league club joins anti-violence campaign

Wintermoon has finally arrived

WARMING UP: Popular band Perch Creek will perform at the upcoming 20th Wintermoon Festival this weekend.

Wintermoon has finally arrived

Latest deals and offers

Throw away the key

IT’S almost time to lock up some local identities to give our youth a leg up in life.

Girl in paradise video evokes Airlie pride

World traveller Nina Wilson, who grew up in the Whitsundays, has made a video showing off the region.

Video captures the beauty of the Whitsundays

Sporting clubs rally against domestic violence

Proserpine and Whitsunday Junior Rugby League Club president Kevin Young and under 16s team Joel Hoffman, Ben Young, Nick Dierna, Josh Colborne, Aden Spence, Oakley Ngakura, Jack Durnsford, Jake Harrison and counsellor Jan Waetford (back), with Jack Handley, Mitch Cann, Ben Cornish, Malachai Lane and Brad Barbeler (front). Photo Lucy Smith / Daily Mercury

Rugby league club joins anti-violence campaign

Wintermoon has finally arrived

WARMING UP: Popular band Perch Creek will perform at the upcoming 20th Wintermoon Festival this weekend.

Wintermoon has finally arrived

Sam Cornish to captain Stingers under 19s

NEED FOR SPEED: Sam Cornish chases after a Townsville player during a North Queensland Championship game.

Rugby union games next week

UPDATE: RSPCA ask for help with dead dogs investigation

No Caption

An image of four dead dogs on Facebook leads to RSPCA investigation.

What's on in the region this long weekend?

Wintermoon Music Festival, Camerons Pocket, April 30th- May 3rd, 2015. Photo Lee Constable / Daily Mercury

Take a look at what's on in the region this long weekend.

Girl in paradise: Whitsundays video

Nina Wilson made a video capturing the beauty of the Whitsundays, where she was...

RACQ releases SE Qld's worst choke points

Paul Turner, RACQ

Paul Turner from RACQ talks about our worst roads at peak time.

British family bashed in Thailand

Family beaten and kicked unconscious by gang in Thailand.

Family beaten and kicked unconscious by gang in Thailand.

Demand for acreage lots pushes up property prices

Property values in Cooroy have increased 25%

Property values jump in Cooroy and Peachester.

How a sacked real estate agent made $725k in four months

Agent is now under investigation by the industry watchdog

RBA warns of future apartment oversupply

Toowoomba: Crest Apartments and Burke & Wills, Ruthven Street ( view from Neil Street) Photo Bev Lacey / The Chronicle

RBA says oversupply of apartments poses risk to household finances