Lifestyle

Mid-size SUV Test: Mazda CX-5 vs Ford Escape vs VW Tiguan

BATTLEGROUND: Put to the mid-size SUV test are the Mazda CX-5, VW Tiguan and Ford Escape
BATTLEGROUND: Put to the mid-size SUV test are the Mazda CX-5, VW Tiguan and Ford Escape

THE evidence is there on every street. Compact SUVs have become our preferred means of carrying kids and cargo - and new arrivals just keep coming.   

Mazda has just brought out a new model of the CX-5, Australia's top selling SUV for the past four years.   

Ford has facelifted the Kuga and renamed it with the global Escape badge.  

We're running them against the award-winning Volkswagen Tiguan.  

Ford Escape

Ford Escape
Ford Escape

 

This is Ford's third attempt in five years at cracking the compact SUV segment.  

There are more variants, from $34,000 drive-away to $53,535 drive-away.  

We have the Trend 1.5 front-driver, the middle of the range, which is $39,050 drive-away as tested (including a $1300 safety pack and $550 for metallic paint).  

The new name also brings a new nose and engine, plus an impressive list of advanced - but optional - safety tech. Standard are seven airbags, rear camera (with guiding lines that turn) and rear sensors.  

The safety pack adds automatic emergency braking (which now works from 50km/h rather than 30kmh), radar cruise control, lane keeping assistance, rear cross traffic alert and blind spot warning. These options take the Trend from the least equipped to the best among this trio.  

Update items also include Apple Car Play and Android Auto, built-in navigation with traffic alerts and digital radio joins AM/FM.  

The Trend comes with push-button start, electronic park brake, cruise control (with speed limiter), auto headlights, rain-sensing wipers and privacy glass, among other mod-cons.   

A power tailgate adds $1200.  

The cabin is basic but practical; the others have a more up-market appearance but less tech.  

Deft touches: digital speed display, dual zone aircon, two USB ports, a 12V socket and four map lights - plus a light and 12V socket in the cargo area, which expands from 406L to 1603L.  

The rear seat splits 60-40. The seat back angle can be adjusted but the base doesn't slide forward. As with the others, there are two Isofix child seat anchor points and three top tether mounts.  

The 1.5 turbo petrol engine replaces the 1.6 turbo that was recalled a fortnight ago following a spate of fires, including seven in Australia.   It's an economical engine with plenty of oomph - and costs about half as much to service as the others. As with many modern engines, it demands premium unleaded.  

These aren't supposed to be race cars but we checked their 0-100kmh times as an indicator of how they'll haul the family in the daily grind.  

The Escape - slightly faster than the VW Tiguan and one second quicker to the speed limit than the Mazda CX-5 - handles corners confidently, but the suspension can get a bit busier than the others over bumps. At times, the steering feels too sharp for the size and weight of the car.  

Mazda CX-5

Mazda CX-5
Mazda CX-5

Mazda expands the range to four model grades - from $34,500 drive-away to $54,700 drive-away.  

We have the Maxx Sport (the second model up) 2.0 petrol front-drive at $38,400 drive-away.  

Mazda loads the new model with the most standard safety kit of the trio, including automatic emergency braking (front and rear), rear cross traffic alert and blind zone warning. This is in addition to six airbags, a rear view camera and rear sensors.  

Apple Car Play and Android Auto are still not available but built-in navigation is standard on this grade. The tablet-style display in the dash looks classy but is not a touchscreen.  

The cabin has an up-market feel but the door pockets are smaller than the others, there's no digital speed display, and the guiding lines on the rear camera don't turn.  

The driver's side mirror is not convex, so it's hard to see traffic in the adjacent lane. I'd prefer a wider view rather than rely on a small warning light in the corner of the mirror.  

Unique among this trio, the rear seat splits 40-20-40 and can be dropped via a lever in the cargo area. The seat back angle can be adjusted but the base does not slide forward. Cargo capacity is 442L/1342L.  

On the move the Mazda is quieter than before - finally muting its road noise on par with rivals.  

Performance from the non-turbo 2.0 is similar to these peers. Helpfully, it takes regular unleaded.   

A downside: the CX-5 is the dearest of this trio to service.  

The new CX-5 steers well, with a plush and almost cushy ride, rather than the razor-sharp feeling of its predecessor.  

VW Tiguan

VW Tiguan
VW Tiguan

Despite its premium price, the Tiguan is selling at twice the rate of the Escape and Honda CR-V and is closing the gap on the Subaru Forester.  

The range stretches from $39,100 drive-away to $54,580 drive-away. We tested the 110TSI Trendline DSG front-drive, at $39,900 drive-away including $700 for metallic paint.  

Standard fare includes automatic emergency braking, rear camera with guiding lines that turn, front and rear parking sensors, large touchscreen with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto but not built-in navigation.  

Radar cruise control and lane keeping assistance (optional on all Escapes and standard on the top grade CX-5) are not available as an option on this grade.  

The Tiguan has the most spacious cabin and the biggest storage pockets. As with the others it has rear air vents. Unlike the others, it has single zone aircon.  

The Tiguan is the only one among this trio with a sliding back seat - to create a larger cargo area (from 615L to 1665L with the seats down) as well as seat back angle adjustment.  

Its 1.4 turbo, the smallest of the three, does the job, albeit on premium unleaded.  

The twin clutch automatic gearbox takes half a second or so to engage but you soon learn to adapt your driving style and release the brake pedal a little sooner.  

Its biggest asset is the way it drives. The Tiguan has the most precise steering and handling feel, and yet it's also the most comfortable over bumps. That's a gratifying double act.  

Verdict

Escape vs CX-5 vs Tiguan
Escape vs CX-5 vs Tiguan

The Escape, though more compelling than previously, doesn't drive quite as well as the others and isn't as well presented inside. If the optional safety pack were fitted standard, it would have aced this test.  

Still a class act, the Tiguan is the best here for space, comfort, practicality and driving feel. But the competition has caught up with more standard features for the money.  

With its impressive list of standard safety gear, up-market interior and greater refinement, the CX-5 Maxx Sport wins this round. Undercutting the others on price is a bonus.  

The contenders' vital statistics

Mazda CX-5 Maxx Sport

CARSGUIDE - 3 car comparison. Ford Escape, Volkswagen Tiguan and Mazda CX-5. Picture: Supplied
CARSGUIDE - 3 car comparison. Ford Escape, Volkswagen Tiguan and Mazda CX-5. Picture: Supplied

PRICE: $38,400 drive-away (as tested)  

WARRANTY: 3 years/ unlimited km  

CAPPED SERVICING: $1405 over 3 years  

SERVICE INTERVAL: 12 months/10,000km  

SAFETY: 5 stars, 6 airbags  

ENGINE: 2.0-litre 4-cylinder, 114kW/200Nm  

TRANSMISSION: 6-speed auto; FWD  

THIRST: 6.9L/100km  

DIMENSIONS: 4550mm (L), 1840mm (W), 1675mm (H), 2700mm (WB)  

WEIGHT: 1556kg  

SPARE: Space-saver  

TOWING: 1800kg  

VW Tiguan Trendline

CARSGUIDE - 3 car comparison. Ford Escape, Volkswagen Tiguan and Mazda CX-5. Picture: Supplied
CARSGUIDE - 3 car comparison. Ford Escape, Volkswagen Tiguan and Mazda CX-5. Picture: Supplied

PRICE: $39,900 drive-away (as tested)  

WARRANTY: 3 years/ unlimited km  

CAPPED SERVICING: $1336 over 3 years  

SERVICE INTERVAL: 12 months/15,000km  

SAFETY: 5 stars, 7 airbags  

ENGINE: 1.4-litre 4-cyliner turbo, 110kW/250Nm  

TRANSMISSION: 6-speed DSG; FWD  

THIRST: 6.3L/100km  

DIMENSIONS: 4486mm (L), 1839mm (W), 1648mm (H), 2681mm (WB)  

WEIGHT: 1450kg  

SPARE: Space-saver  

TOWING: 1800kg  

Ford Escape Trend

The 2017 Ford Escape.
The 2017 Ford Escape.

PRICE: $39,050 drive-away (as tested)  

WARRANTY: 3 years/ 100,000km  

CAPPED SERVICING: $780 over 3 years  

SERVICE INTERVAL: 12 months/15,000km  

SAFETY: 5 stars, 7 airbags  

ENGINE: 1.5-litre 4-cylinder turbo, 134kW/240Nm  

TRANSMISSION: 6-speed auto; FWD  

THIRST: 7.2L/100km  

DIMENSIONS: 4524mm (L), 1838mm (W), 1749mm (H), 2690mm (WB)  

WEIGHT: 1607kg  

SPARE: Space-saver  

TOWING: 1500kg    

News Corp Australia

Topics:  comparison ford escape mazda cx-5 motoring review road test suv test test volkswagen vw tiguan


Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

The world is invited to Whitsunday SESsions

Gavin "Butto" Butlin, Ellie Hanlon, Rob Cole, Mark Connors, Troy Jones and Kieran McCarthy (back) and Courtney Anderson, Daniel Moss, Leigh Munro (front) are ready to rock for Whitsunday SESsions.

Whitsunday SESsions will be live streamed across the world.

Council counts the cost of Debbie

The Airlie Beach Lagoon was closed due to damage from Tropical Cyclone Debbie in March.

It's a high cost to get the lagoon back to its original state

A warm Whitsunday welcome to Today Show

HANDS UP: Today Show weather presenter Natalia Cooper with Airlie Beach locals at Abell Point Marina yesterday morning.

The Today Show was welcomed to the Whitsundays this morning

Local Partners

New design coming to Airlie Beach roundabout

WHEN the Airlie Beach main street roundabout was stripped of its starfish one year ago, the question arose of what would replace it.

Debbie's graveyard: Major auction to clear written-off cars

Auto Repair and Towing Service owner Shane Muntelwit at the salvage yard behind Mackay Airport, which has become a graveyard for about 150 vehicles destroyed or written off by Cyclone Debbie.

A salvage yard has become a makeshift graveyard

What to expect at Birds of Tokyo's Ipswich gig

The band will perform at the Racehorse Hotel on Friday.

BAND member Glen Sarangapany talks music, pub grub and doing shoeys

What public holidays are left in 2017

Ipswich residents will get the day off tomorrow for the show.

IPSWICH residents will get tomorrow off for the show

Rebel Wilson says she didn’t have to lie to make it

I’M not glamorous, but that doesn’t make me a liar: that’s the message from Rebel Wilson on her second day in the witness box.

All bets on Judah to win battle to become the Voice

Judah Kelly from The Voice.

Judah Kelly is the clear favourite to win the competition.

Pirates in Whitsundays

ON SET: Pitaes of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales, filming on Whitehaven Beach in July 2015.

The fifth instalment hits cinemas on Thursday

Kim Kardashian slammed over Manchester tribute

Kim Kardashian's tribute to Manchester didn't go down well

Top Gun 2 movie is happening, Tom Cruise confirms

Tom Cruise in a scene from the movie Top Gun.

TOM Cruise delights fans with announcement on Sunrise.

The first Baywatch movie reviews are in

From left, Jon Bass, Alex Daddario, Zac Efron, Dwayne Johnson, Kelly Rohrbach, and Ilfenesh Hadera in a scene from the movie Baywatch.

Critics were less than impressed.

A warm Whitsunday welcome to Today Show

HANDS UP: Today Show weather presenter Natalia Cooper with Airlie Beach locals at Abell Point Marina yesterday morning.

The Today Show was welcomed to the Whitsundays this morning

How Toowoomba house prices compare in Australia

For sale sign in front of home.

Here's what $700,000 will buy you in Toowoomba, Brisbane and Sydney

One of Maryborough's most historic homes is still for sale

FULL OF HISTORY: Trisha Moulds is owner of the historic Tinana state known as Rosehill. The beautiful home is currently for sale.

It has been the scene of both joy and tragedies over the years.

The face of the Sunshine Coast's overpriced rental crisis

Alyx Wilson had to rent a $385 unit in Currimundi because the market was too competitive for cheaper rental housing. She is now renting a room from friends who own a house in Currimundi, and says its much more affordable.

Young people feel the strain in competitive, expensive rental market

WATCH: Take a tour of a tradie's dream home

5a Bruce Hiskens Court, Norman Gardens, going for $720,000. INSET: Lea Taylor.

Huge block with potential for anything

Ready to SELL your property?

Post Your Ad Here!